Plaintiffs,
the polygamous family featured on the TLC reality series "Sister
Wives," sued seeking a declaratory judgment that Utah's ban on plural
marriage is unconstitutional. Plaintiffs are members of a religious group that
believes polygamy is a core religious practice.
Federal district Judge Clark Waddoups held that the portion of the
statute barring cohabitation while married to someone else is unconstitutional
as a violation of free exercise rights.
Concluding
that in operation the ban is not applied neutrally, but is primarily used to
target religious co-habitation, the court held that the ban is subject to
strict scrutiny, and fails that test.
Judge Waddoups also concludes that the ban, under a rational basis
review, violates plaintiffs' rights to be free from government interference in
matters of consensual sexual privacy, and is void for vagueness. In ruling on
this portion of the statute, the court said that it was not constrained by the
U.S. Supreme Court's 1878 decision in Reynolds v. United States upholding the
federal anti-bigamy statute because that decision dealt only with a ban on
multiple marriages, not on cohabitation while married.
Read
more about this on Breitbart News.
No comments:
Post a Comment